Moderate — ~20 monthsNew York

Erie Supreme (Buffalo) Venue Guide

25 Delaware Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14202

20mo

Avg. to Trial

~3,500

Court PI Filings

Supreme

Court Type

E-Filing

Jury Pool Characteristics

Working-class, blue-collar Western New York jury pool

Generally moderate-to-plaintiff-friendly — sympathetic to injury victims

Strong labor union heritage influences community perspectives

Less sophisticated than NYC juries but genuinely empathetic

Filing Procedures

  1. 1

    E-filing mandatory through NYSCEF

  2. 2

    Index number filing fee: $210 (RJI additional $95)

  3. 3

    RJI required for judge assignment

  4. 4

    Erie County Supreme Court sits in downtown Buffalo

Local Rules & Requirements

  • Pure comparative fault under CPLR 1411

  • No-fault serious injury threshold applies

  • Erie County has a dedicated trial part for PI cases

  • Winter weather conditions are frequently relevant to accident cases

Strategic Tips

  1. 1

    Buffalo juries are generally sympathetic to injury victims — the working-class community values fairness

  2. 2

    I-90 (NY Thruway) and I-190 corridor accidents are the most common case types

  3. 3

    Severe winter weather (lake-effect snow) is a major factor in many accidents — document conditions thoroughly

  4. 4

    Cross-border Canadian traffic from the Peace Bridge adds international complexity

Frequently Asked Questions — Erie Supreme (Buffalo)

Compare

Other Court Venues

New York

Albany Supreme

~20 months • Moderate

New York

Dutchess County (Poughkeepsie)

~20 months • Moderate

New York

Onondaga County (Syracuse)

~20 months • Moderate

Browse 725 Profiled Court Venues

Sources & Methodology

Disposition times: Based on state court annual reports and the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) State Court Caseload Digest (2023). Estimated averages for personal injury civil cases; actual timelines vary by case complexity.

Caseload figures: Derived from state court annual reports and NCSC Court Statistics Project data where available.

Filing procedures & fees: From court websites and published local rules of court, current as of early 2026. Fees and procedures are subject to change.

Jury pool characteristics: Based on county demographic data (U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2022), county-level jury verdict reporters, and published local bar association litigation guides.

Disclaimer: Court venue profiles are for educational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Procedures, fees, and timelines change frequently. Verify all information with the court clerk's office before filing.

Filing in Buffalo?

Our attorneys know Erie Supreme (Buffalo) inside and out. Free consultation — pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you.

📞 (866) 423-7724 — Free Consultation